Idiotic premise.
Yet somehow I got through this novel.
The Burning Library (2025) by Gilly Macmillan tries to be a fast-paced historical mystery reminiscent of The Da Vinci Code, packed with a distinct feminist twist, hidden codes, and rival secret societies.
The idiotic premise is the rivalry between 2 secret organizations of women:
- The Order of St. Katherine: Traditionalists who believe women exercise true control by pulling strings from the shadows and influencing powerful men.
- The Fellowship of the Larks: Reformers determined to actively amass overt positions of power and leadership for women across major societal institutions
Both want to improve the lives of women — yet try to kill each over a legendary medieval manuscript known as the Book of Wonders, which holds the promise of immense influence and power.
It makes no sense that they don’t work together.
If you suspend your disbelief, you might enjoy it.
I did enjoy the setting ➙ the wind-swept Scottish coast and the dark, oak-paneled academic corridors of St Andrews, Scotland.
The writing is good.
And many of the characters made me care about what happened to them.
