This book didn’t do it for me.
Is it a ghost story? Murder mystery?
The characters are unlikable. And make inexplicably dumb decisions.
A Box Full of Darkness (2026) is frustrating.
The narrative alternates perspectives among three adult siblings—Violet, Vail, and Dodie Esmie—who share a traumatic and neglected childhood.
- The Disappearance: Eighteen years prior, their six-year-old brother, Ben, vanished without a trace during an innocent game of hide-and-seek inside their family home.
- The Call Home: After decades of estrangement and running from their past, the siblings are forced into a reluctant homecoming. The vacant house’s terrified groundskeeper quits after witnessing the ghost of a young boy.
- The Supernatural Burden: Each sibling has been uniquely tormented by distinct paranormal phenomena since childhood. Violet can see the dead and is haunted by a menacing spirit called “Sister”. Vail is plagued by memories of beaming lights and probing figures. Dodie suffers from violent nightmares of drowning.
- The Mystery: Back at Fell House, the trio must piece together their fractured memories to uncover what truly happened to Ben. However, they soon realize that an even more ancient, sinister entity is waiting for them in the dark
The conclusion … unsatisfying.











