should Canada separate from Quebec?

The two times Quebec voted on separation from Canada, I had mixed feelings.

I could see the logic. And pondered whether, ultimately, both Quebec and R.O.C. (Rest Of Canada) might be better off.

Neither vote passed.

Today Quebec manages to convince the rest of Canada that they are a “have not” Province. That Québécois should be subsided by the rich Provinces.

How is that?

The Québécois friends in my industry are better off than Albertans, and have always been better off.

Here’s a brilliant article, I think, on the issue of Equalization payments.

As you’ve likely heard, Greece is “too big to fail”. The rest of the EU has decided to bail them out.

In Greece, citizens, on average, retire at the age of 58.

In Germany, the citizens expected to help bail out the bankrupt Greeks, work on average until until the age of 65. Naturally, German citizens are wondering how this can be considered fair. Why should they work seven years longer on average so Greek citizens can live a life of leisure and be less productive?

What’s more, in Germany, most working people pay taxes. In Greece, only 20 per cent pay taxes. Again, unfair. And yet equalization between “have” European Union states and “have not” European Union states continues, even though it’s not making things equal — it’s rewarding laziness, leisure and possibly even criminal tax evasion. Why pay taxes if some hard-working Germans will do it for you? Thus the riots in Greece. They believe they are entitled to those entitlements.

Dysfunctional? You bet. We Canadians would never stand for such a thing. Right? Think again.

Equalization in Canada was established to ensure that “have-not” regions could enjoy the same programs as “have” regions and most Canadians wouldn’t quibble with that. But that has not happened. In fact, the reverse has occurred. The have provinces have fewer services than the have-nots.

According to a Dec. 2009 report by the Institute of Statistics of Quebec, Quebecers average age of retirement is 62 whereas in the rest of Canada it is almost 65. While the Quebec Pension Plan and Canada Pension Plans are identical and carry the same penalties for collecting your pension earlier than 65, those who stop working earlier are less productive and contribute less to Canadian society in terms of income and taxes.

In light of the fact that Quebec received $8.6 billion in equalization payments in 2010-11 out of a total equalization pot of $14.4 billion, it’s safe to say that citizens in Canada’s “have” provinces — British Columbia, Alberta and Ontario — are paying for Quebecers’ early retirement, as theirs is the only province which has such a generous, early retirement benefit.

In other words, equalization is not very equal. …

Calgary Herald – Corbella: It’s all Greek to Quebec

Licia Corbella has worked for daily newspapers for more than 20 years and is currently the Calgary Herald’s Editorial Page Editor. …

What’s the solution?

Cancel equalization payments, Canada. Or separate from Quebec.

related – Equalization payments in Canada

Jon Stewart vs FOX News

An interesting article by BRIAN STELTER of the obviously Commie NY Times …

… Fox News Channel is Jon Stewart’s new enemy No. 1. …

Comedian Jon Stewart’s job of host on The Daily Show has been renewed until into 2013. Is that good or bad news for FOX?

Both, I’d say.

… he may well be television’s pre-eminent fact-checker of Fox News, the nation’s highest-rated cable news channel.

It has been noticed by, among other people, the Fox host Bill O’Reilly, who called Mr. Stewart a “devoted critic” of Fox News and said “his influence is growing.” …

Personally I’m sick of Jon Stewart. But thrilled that somebody is raking FOX News over the coals.

As Jon Stewart says, FOX News is “truly a terrible, cynical, disingenuous news organization.”

Yet millions of people believe the many bald-faced lies told on FOX interspersed between actual news.

O’Reilly responded to Mr. Stewart on his Fox program on Wednesday, calling “The Daily Show” a “key component of left-wing television” …

Not. The Daily Show has independent writers who have no hot line to the White House. It’s on a Comedy Network. If Bill O’Reilly was on the Comedy Network, I wouldn’t complain. I’d chuckle.

FOX News parrots Republican Party talking points on multiple TV shows all day long. I’m embarrassed to have been born in an era where FOX News could be so successful. The end of the world is nigh.

a battle of wits

read the article for yourself – Jon Stewart’s Punching Bag, Fox News

simplifying legal jargon

Alan Siegel is my hero.

Tax forms, credit agreements, healthcare legislation: They’re crammed with gobbledygook, says Alan Siegel, and incomprehensibly long. He calls for a simple, sensible redesign — and plain English — to make legal paperwork intelligible to the rest of us.

health care anger

I’ve just arrived back in the U.S.A. after several weeks not following the insanely convoluted American political process on that debate.

… A USA Today/Gallup poll showed a plurality now favored the new law — yes, favored. After months of Republicans saying Democrats were going against the will of the people, a plurality — 49 to 40 percent — said passing the bill was “a good thing,” …

NY Times Opinion piece – House of Anger

The people have spoken. A small majority think that the Health Care legislation is an improvement.

That’s democracy.

Suck it up, buttercup.

Why are opponents so ungracious in defeat?

As Colbert would say, “WHY DO YOU REPUBLICANS HATE DEMOCRACY“?

I respect the opinions of those against the Bill. But I have no tolerance for anyone who breaks the law in frustration over losing the vote.

Lock ’em up.

Harper “pouring money down a rat hole”

So says Craig Jones, executive director of the John Howard Society regarding the Canadian prison system.

Why is the Harper government taking millions more dollars out of our pockets in times of massive deficit?

… expenditures for the coming fiscal year will increase 43 per cent, to $329.4 million in 2010-2011, from $230.8 million in 2009-2010 …

Calgary Herald

If the Americans have taught us anything, it’s that longer prison sentences don’t work in reducing crime.

The best moment in the movie Sicko was the scene showing that the vile terrorists get better Health Care in Guantanamo Bay than survivors of the American families victimized. The health personnel-to-detainee ratio is 1 to 4 there.

Perhaps Harper should look more closely at the Mexican prison system. In Mexico prisoners are expected to pay for their own cost of incarceration. Work camps are a far better deterrent than free dental.

prp

Sarah Palin CHEATS on interview – pitiful

Sarah Palin was lobbed a softball question at the right wing Tea Party Convention Q&A session, February 6, 2010.

Just to make sure she could remember all 3 talking points, Sarah double-checked the notes scrawled on her hand.

Click PLAY or watch it on YouTube.

Even a co-worker on her employer’s network, FOX news, poked fun at Palin’s palm notes.

Republicans, you’re going to let this creampuff debate Obama?

Find a better candidate.

would Americans elect Sarah Palin?

Sadly, this photo of Sarah Palin is a fake.

Sad because it’s quite representative of her.

I’m reading that Palin is leading other potential Republican candidates for the 2012 election. Are the Republicans really that hard up?

She would be a disastrous President. An international embarrassment.

Yet the U.S.A. just might elect this unqualified woman. They elected an incoherent named Scott Brown recently, in a protest vote.

BBC poses another good question about Americans: Why do people vote against their own interests?

… it is striking that the people who most dislike the whole idea of healthcare reform- the ones who think it is socialist, godless, a step on the road to a police state – are often the ones it seems designed to help.

In Texas, where barely two-thirds of the population have full health insurance and over a fifth of all children have no cover at all, opposition to the legislation is currently running at 87%. …

I can understand a Texan voting against Obama. But I can’t understand what they see in Palin.

It’s not just me. I traveled for months in Europe and Asia last year. Not one non-American I spoke with liked Bush, McCain or Palin. Why do Americans vote for these people?

Enlighten me in a comment.

Obama vs Steve Jobs

On Wednesday two major news stories dropped the same day:

1) the unveiling of the Apple iPad and
2) President Obama’s State of the Union speech

We wondered: what would people talk about more? Was the announcement of Apple’s Tablet Steve Jobs potentially more captivating than Obama’s first State of the Union speech?

Mashable – Steve Jobs vs. Obama: Who Got the Bigger Buzz?

ripped off by Canada Post

UPDATE: It looks like the claims in this post are false. See details in the COMMENTS.

Here’s the response we got back from Canada Post:

Over the holidays, a customer contacted us by email to ask us why private sector partners would be allowed to charge more for the same service provided by corporate offices. The reply they received contained misinformation and we would like our customers to know the facts – rates are the same at all Canada Post establishments both corporate and private sector partner locations.

It is very important to us that your customer experience is the same no matter where you choose to shop.

In fact, the agreement that Canada Post has with its private sector partners specifies that the maximum postal rates that they can charge are the Canada Post published rates. If a postal outlet charges prices that are over the Canada Post published rates, they are in violation of their contract. You should also know that the equipment used by private sector postal outlets is programmed with Canada Post’s published rates. Therefore, the rates should be the same no matter where you choose to get postal services.

We are very disappointed to hear of this experience and we are investigating the matter. If you have any questions or concerns about our rates, contact us at http://canadapost.ca/contactus

AND another response by email:

It is very important to us that the customer experience is the same no matter where our customers choose to shop.

With respect to the rates, all of our 6,000 automated post offices, corporate or dealer use the same Retail point-of-sale system software and corporate rating engine. Therefore they all charge the same rate for the same identical service.

Dealers cannot charge a higher rate for a postal service, as the system will not permit it and contractually they would be in default.

We will further investigate the matter that you brought to our attention.

Regards,

Pam Larose
Customer Service
Canada Post

==== original post from Jan 13th:

Postal rates in the Great White North were increased Jan. 11th.

I think we should avoid using Canada Post as much as possible. The pricing system they use is silly.

photo by just another teuchter in canada

Not that prices are too high. My complaint is that there is no fairness to the pricing.

For example, in 2006 David Grant compared mailing costs for the same package:

Vancouver to Florida $6.65 Small Packet USA Surface
Vancouver to Florida $7.90 Small Packet USA Air
FedEx Ground Vancouver to Toronto $12.

Vancouver to Toronto via Canada Post Regular Parcel is $10.34

Canada Post Rates Rant

Do those rates seem sensible to you? Who comes up with these pricing formulas?

More recently, a blogger mailed two identical packages via Canada Post, one week apart.

From a Canada Post postal outlet, cost was $11.74. Next week … a clerk at a Canada Post office said the $11.74 on the second package was not enough. He’d have to buy $6 more in postage.

WHAT!?

That story came in by email from George. It’s posted in the comments.

Veronika Strofski, Customer Service Canada Post, explains:

Only Canada Post Depots and Corporate Post Offices are obligated to follow the price of stamps and postal products that are legislated by Canada Post. Any commercial and private establishment (e.g. convenience store or pharmacy) may charge extra fees as a convenience to their customers. It is at their discretion to apply additional service fees to products that they sell. We suggest visiting a Corporate Post Office in order to avoid paying additional service charges ….

Why haven’t I ever heard about these extra charges?

Seems those extra charges do not exist.

I’ll forward these complaints to Canada Post’s current Ombudsman: Ms. Nicole Goodfellow.

As at most bogus organizations, there’s no email contact. Only phone. Or mail. She really doesn’t want to hear from Canadians.

… On another page I found the address: ombud@ombudsman.postescanadapost.ca

I’ve still not heard back from the Ombudswoman. Who’s the Ombudsman for Ombudsmen?

Bottom line: In Canada, avoid snail mail. Do as much as possible online. Or by FAX.